invention
In 1970 an American ABS luggage
executive unscrewed four castors from a wardrobe and fixed them to a suitcase. Then he put
a strap on his contraption and trotted it gleefully around his house.
This was how Bernard Sadow invented the world’s first rolling suitcase. It happened
roughly 5,000 years after the invention of the wheel and barely one year after Nasa
managed to put two men on the surface of the moon using the largest rocket ever built. We
had driven an electric rover with wheels on a foreign heavenly body and even invented the
hamster wheel. So why did it take us so long to put wheels on suitcases? This has become
something of a classic mystery of innovation.
Nobel prize-winning economist Robert Shiller discusses the matter in two different
books, Narrative Economics and The New Financial Order. He sees it as an archetypal
example of how innovation can be a very slow-footed thing: how the “blindingly obvious”
can stare us expectantly in the face for an eternity.
Nassim Nicholas Taleb is another world-renowned thinker who has pondered the mystery.
Having lugged heavy suitcases through airports and railway stations for years, he was
astonished by his own unquestioning acceptance of the status quo. Taleb sees the rolling
suitcase as a parable of how we often tend to ignore the simplest solutions. As humans, we
strive for the difficult, grandiose and complex. Technology – such as having wheels on
suitcases – may appear obvious in hindsight, but that doesn’t mean it was obvious.
Similarly, in management and innovation literature, the late invention of the rolling
suitcase often appears as somewhat of a warning. A reminder of our limitations as
innovators.
But there is one factor that these thinkers have missed. I stumbled upon it when I was
researching my book on women and innovation. I found a photo in a newspaper archive of a
woman in a fur coat pulling a suitcase on wheels. It made me stop in my tracks because it
was from 1952, 20 years before the official “invention” of the rolling suitcase.
Fascinated, I kept looking. Soon, a completely different story about our limitations as
innovators was rolling out
The modern suitcase was born at the end of the 19th century. When mass tourism first
took off, Europe’s large railway stations were inundated with porters, who would help
passengers with their bags. But, by the middle of the 20th century, the porters were
dwindling in number, and passengers increasingly carried their own
PP luggage.
Advertisements for products applying the technology of the wheel to the suitcase can
be found in British newspapers as early as the 1940s. These are not suitcases on wheels,
exactly, but a gadget known as “the portable porter” – a wheeled device that can be
strapped on to a suitcase. But it never really caught on.
In 1967, a Leicestershire woman wrote a sharply worded letter to her local newspaper
complaining that a bus conductor had forced her to buy an additional ticket for her
rolling suitcase. The conductor argued that “anything on wheels should be classed as a
pushchair”. She wondered what he would have done if she had boarded the bus wearing
roller-skates. Would she be charged as a passenger or as a pram?
The woman in the fur coat and the Leicestershire woman on the bus are the vital clues
to this mystery. Suitcases with wheels existed decades before they were “invented” in
1972, but were considered niche products for women. And that a product for women could
make life easier for men or completely disrupt the whole global
ABS+PC luggage industry was not an
idea the market was then ready to entertain.
Resistance to the rolling suitcase had everything to do with gender. Sadow, the
“official” inventor, described how difficult it was to get any US department store
chains to sell it: “At this time, there was this macho feeling. Men used to
carry on luggage
for their wives. It was … the natural thing to do, I guess.”
Two assumptions about gender were at work here. The first was that no man would ever
roll a suitcase because it was simply “unmanly” to do so. The second was about the
mobility of women. There was nothing preventing a woman from rolling a suitcase – she had
no masculinity to prove. But women didn’t travel alone, the industry assumed. If a woman
travelled, she would travel with a man who would then carry her bag for her. This is why
the industry couldn’t see any commercial potential in the rolling suitcase. It took more
than 15 years for the invention to go mainstream, even after Sadow had patented it.
In the 1984 Hollywood film Romancing the Stone, a rolling suitcase is featured as
something of a silly feminine thing. Kathleen Turner’s character insists on bringing her
wheeled suitcase to the jungle, to the great annoyance of Michael Douglas, who is trying
to save them from villains, while tracking down a legendary gigantic emerald.
Then, in 1987, US pilot Robert Plath created the modern cabin bag. He turned Sadow’s
suitcase on its side and made it smaller. In the 1980s, more women started to travel
alone, without a man to carry their spinner luggage set. The wheeled suitcase carried with it a dream
of greater mobility for women.
Bit by bit, the rolling suitcase became a feature of the modern businessman’s
arsenal. We forgot all about the intense and very gendered resistance the product had
encountered. But we shouldn’t – because this story carries some important lessons about
innovation that we need to hear today.
We couldn’t see the genius of the wheeled suitcase because it didn’t align with our
prevailing views on masculinity. In hindsight, we find this bizarre. How could the
predominant view on masculinity turn out to be more stubborn than the market’s desire to
make money? How could the crude idea that men must carry heavy things prevent us from
seeing the potential in a product that would come to transform an entire global industry?
But is it really that surprising? The world is full of people who would rather die
than let go of certain notions of masculinity. Doctrines like “real men don’t eat
vegetables”, “real men don’t get check-ups for minor things” and “real men don’t
have sex with condoms” kill very real men every single day. Our society’s ideas on
masculinity are some of our most unyielding ideas, and our culture often values the
preservation of certain concepts of masculinity over life itself. In this context, such
ideas are certainly powerful enough to hold back technological innovation.
The rolling suitcase is far from the only example. When electric cars first emerged in
the 1800s they came to be seen as “feminine” simply because they were slower and less
dangerous. This held back the size of the electric car market, especially in the US, and
contributed to us building a world for petrol-driven cars. When electric starters for
petrol-driven cars were developed they were also considered to be something for the
ladies. The assumption was that only women were demanding the type of safety measures that
meant being able to start your car without having to crank it at risk of injury. Ideas
about gender similarly delayed our efforts to meet the technological challenges of
producing closed cars because it was seen as “unmanly” to have a roof on your car.
Assumptions about masculinity play a similar role today in relation to innovation
around sustainability. For example, we often think that consumption of meat and
preferences for large cars – instead of travel by public transport – are essential
features of masculinity. This holds innovation back and prevents us from imagining new
ways of living powered by new technologies.
Perhaps in the future we will laugh at our current struggle to get many men to adopt a
more environmentally friendly lifestyle, in the same way that we shake our heads at how
unthinkable it was for a man to wheel his suitcase 40 years ago.
Ideas about gender also limit what we even count as technology. We talk about “the
iron age” and “the bronze age”. We could also talk about “the ceramic age” and “the
flax age”, since these technologies were just as important. But technologies associated
with women are not considered to be inventions in the same way that those associated with
men are.
Gender answers the riddle of why it took 5,000 years for us to put wheels on
suitcases. It’s perhaps easy to think that we wouldn’t make similar mistakes today. But
many of the structural problems are still here. We still have male-dominated industries
not interested in dealing with the fact that women influence 80% of all consumer
decisions. Products are still being built and designed with only men in mind and we have a
financial system that stubbornly refuses to see the potential of women’s ideas.
Today, less than 1% of UK venture capital goes to all-female teams. Among the very few
women who do get funded, a very large majority are white. Of course, venture capital isn’
t everything – there are other ways to fund and scale innovation – but the fact that
men, more or less, have a monopoly is certainly a symptom of an economy where women’s
ideas are not heard.
The many economists and thinkers who have thought about how we didn’t put wheels on
suitcases until 1972 were right to note that this story is a symptom of a larger problem.
It was just a slightly different problem than the one they imagined it to be.
This article was amended on 8 July 2021. Bernard Sadow invented the rolling
suitcase in 1970, not 1972, which was the year the invention was patented.
Mother of Invention: How Good Ideas Get Ignored in an Economy Built for Men by Katrine
Mar?al is published by William Collins (£18.99). To support the Guardian order your copy
at guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply.
More than 1.5 million readers, from 180 countries, have recently taken the step to
support us financially – keeping us open to all, and fiercely independent.
With no shareholders or billionaire owner, we can set our own agenda and provide
trustworthy journalism that’s free from commercial and political influence, offering a
counterweight to the spread of misinformation. When it’s never mattered more, we can
investigate and challenge without fear or favour.
Unlike many others, Guardian journalism is available for everyone to read, regardless
of what they can afford to pay. We do this because we believe in information equality.
Greater numbers of people can keep track of global events, understand their impact on
people and communities, and become inspired to take meaningful action.
We aim to offer readers a comprehensive, international perspective on critical events
shaping our world – from the Black Lives Matter movement, to the new American
administration, Brexit, and the world's slow emergence from a global pandemic. We are
committed to upholding our reputation for urgent, powerful reporting on the climate
emergency, and made the decision to reject advertising from fossil fuel companies, divest
from the oil and gas industries, and set a course to achieve net zero emissions by 2030.
Related ads
Why Wall Art Matters Most In Interior Design
Why Wall Art Matters Most In Interior Design Too often in interior paint design, we see wall art treated as an afterthought. It’s what gets dealt with last, long after the final coat of paint has dried on the walls and all of the furniture has… Adıyaman
FullDiab Drops (Gouttes) Prix Côte d’Ivoire
The French FullDiab Drops bean, likewise called as the kidney bean is a decent other option. Whenever cooked with mind, it tastes great and something like a delicacy. The beans FullDiab Drops (Gouttes) Prix Côte d’Ivoire have predominant fiber content and… Adıyaman
Injection molding
It is usually slow and inefficient to mold thermoplastics using the compression molding techniques described above. In particular, it is necessary to cool a thermoplastic part before removing it from the mold, and this requires that the mass of metal… Adıyaman
Varicone Krém Cena Czech
While pressure stockings Varicone are definitely not a substantial strategy for varicose vein expulsion, they can be viable in decreasing the torment you feel from their reality. These hoses are intended to further develop blood stream, which can likewise… Afyonkarahisar
Quilt, Comforter, Duvet, or Bedspread: What's the Difference?
Visit a bed and bath store, and you'll find aisle after aisle devoted to every type of bedding. There are soft, comfortable sheets that make sliding into bed a joy; blankets that warm up chilly winter nights, and many different types of bedding toppers.… Adıyaman
jialaitefc.com
Perhaps it's all the gorgeous festival beauty looks, but lately we've had the urge to go full-on cotton candy with our locks. There's something about pastel-hued, hair-chalked strands that speaks to our inner wild child—and we'll be… Afyonkarahisar
Transformer: What is it? (Definition And Working Principle)
What is a Transformer? A transformer is defined as a passive electrical device that transfers electrical energy from one circuit to another through the process of electromagnetic induction. It is most commonly used to increase (‘step up’) or… Aksaray
What Your Sunglasses Say About You
What Your Sunglasses Say About You Sunglasses are a real character builder. Or at least they play a large roll in the character that you play to others. They’re front and center and they can literally change the shape of your face. So before you… Adıyaman
What's The Difference Between Shirt And T-shirt?
What's The Difference Between Shirt And T-shirt? Tshirts and shirts are two different terms often used interchangeably, but what is the difference between a shirt and a T-shirt? A shirt can be a short-sleeved or long-sleeved garment… Amasya
All About Pneumatic Nailers
Air-powered nail guns offer many advantages that the hammer-and-nail approach, no matter how honorable, can’t hope to match. What Counts: • Type of fastener • Maximum and minimum length of the fastener • Ease of clearing nail jams • Easy-to-use depth… Adıyaman
https://www.wellbiotricks.com/order-gluco-pro-za
HURRY UP!!! ORDER NOW! HURRY UP!!! High levels of glucose in the blood are the defining characteristic of diabetes, which is a chronic neurological illness. Type 1 diabetes and type 2 diabetes are the two most common versions of the disease. Contrary to… Adıyaman
Wide Application of High Shear Emulsifying Machine
Wide Application of High Shear Emulsifying Machine High shear emulsifying machinef is our new product with advanced technology from home and abroad, which strictly complies with the GMP requirement. It is widely used for mixing, dispersing,… Afyonkarahisar
J.J. within the Room: “Wattup coming for the Cardinals security
Very first off, no, I not apologizing for that pun.Minute, I including towards say I expected the J.J. Watt signing—but fairly Kyler Murray Jersey, I was simply throwing the strategy out there as a likelihood. I was as amazed as everyone once the signing… Afyonkarahisar
Funginorm Crema Precio Chile
Nail Organism Funginorm otherwise called Onychomycosis. Contagious nail contamination is a disease of the nails by a growth. Nail organism is exceptionally normal around the world.As they develop they attack and feed on the protein that makes up the hard… Afyonkarahisar
PCSO EZ2 Lotto Result Today
The complete and official 2D EZ2 draw results for Today are listed below. While the actual draw is taking place, updates to the ez2 result today are posted. https://ez2resulttoday.com/ The most recent results above are announced at 2pm, 5pm and 9pm… Afyonkarahisar
Separating out foods into component molecules
Separating out foods into component molecules Food is made up of many different chemical can components or parts, including vitamins, minerals, sugars, fibres, water, lipids, proteins and starches. In addition to these main nutrient… Adıyaman
Anthony Davis believes Lakers would incorporate
Each time Anthony Davis built the choice in the direction of waive his $4 million exchange kicker for the Los Angeles Lakers, he did hence with just one participant within just thoughts: Kawhi Leonard. Experienced Davis declined toward waive his exchange… Adıyaman
The Benefits and Application of Steel Pipes
Steel pipes have various advantages for your next industrial or residential project. Steel tubing is used in a variety of industries, from industrial manufacturing to sculpture. One of the applications for steel tube is in plumbing, where it is used to… Adıyaman
Why Should You Choose Colored Hair Wigs
Summer is coming, How can you fill in the colors for your Summer season? Maybe you can try to give up the wigs with natural colors and choose more adventurous and colorful hairstyles. Choosing green, blue, pink or purple wigs can give you a new sense of… Adıyaman
Curalife Uses- Experience,Ingredients
Official Site https://www.healthnews360.org/curalife-reviews/ https://www.healthnews360.org/illuderma/ Curalife Curalife Reviews Curalife Uses Curalife Experience Curalife Ingredients Curalife Buy Maintaining healthy blood sugar levels is crucial for… Afyonkarahisar
China 12-Strip Tubes
China 12-Strip Tubes Our History Welso has been a trusted supplier of laboratory and medical instruments as well as consumables in China since its foundation. We mainly supply centrifuge, ultrasonic cleaners and other sample preparation instruments and… Adıyaman
Onycosolve PLUS Sprey Fiyat Türkiye
Nail Parasite Onycosolve PLUS otherwise called Onychomycosis. Contagious nail disease is a contamination of the nails by a growth. Nail parasite is extremely normal around the world. It is Onycosolve PLUS Sprey Fiyat Türkiye uncommon in kids yet the… Ankara
What is Borosilicate Glass and How is it Used?
Borosilicate Glass is a specialized form of glass that uses boric acid as a component in its fabrication. The result of the addition of the element boron is a type of glass that is very resistant to thermal shock and exhibits a much lower… Aksaray
Advantages of Concrete Pumping on a Construction Project
Advantages of Concrete Pumping on a Construction Project Concrete pump supplies are an essential part of owning a concrete pumping truck. Where do you find concrete pump parts and concrete pump accessories, like concrete pump straight pipe, when… Afyonkarahisar
Do 360 Lace Front Human Hair Wigs Look Natural
Unless you’re dressing up for Halloween or cosplaying, most people want their 360 Wigs to look as beautiful and natural as possible. If you suffer from hair loss, you’ll also want any coverage to be completely undetectable.Of course, natural-looking wigs… Adıyaman
Overview of CNC Machining Process
Evolving from the numerical control (NC) machining process which utilized punched tape cards, CNC machiningis a manufacturing process which utilizes computerized controls to operate and manipulate machine and cutting tools to shape stock material—e.g.,… Adıyaman
Are stinky inflatable pool toys putting your kids at risk?
Are stinky inflatable pool toys putting your kids at risk? Are stinky inflatable pool toys putting your kids at risk? The researchers expressed concern that some of the products contain potentially hazardous chemicals that could pose a… Adıyaman
Choosing the Right Folder-Gluer
The search for a new folder-gluer can be very daunting. There are many folder-gluer OEMs out there and each have different models, features and sizes designed for a variety of applications. When a finisher or folding carton manufacturer is in the market… Adıyaman
How to Pick A Lawn Mower
How to Pick A Lawn Mower How to Pick A Lawn Mower According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), traditional gasoline lawn mower is a public nuisance to say the least. Using one of them for an hour generates as many volatile… Adana
hz-bottle.com
Common uses for glass liquor bottles include food condiments, soda, liquor, cosmetics, pickling and preservatives; they are occasionally also notably used for the informal distribution of notes. These types of bottles are utilitarian and serve a purpose… Amasya